Graham Cracker Crust

This simple Graham Cracker Crust is a classic recipe, perfect for so many different types of pies! It requires just four ingredients that are pressed into the pie plate, and I'm showing you the easiest way to do it.

Sometimes, you just need a super easy, no-brainer pie crust, and this Homemade Graham Cracker Crust recipe checks all those boxes! Using just a few simple ingredients, this versatile crust adds a delightful sweetness and crunch that is perfect for cheesecakes (or cheesecake pies like this Blueberry Cream Cheese Pie), tarts (like Honeynut Tart), and no-bake pies (like this Banana Cream Pie).

If you are new to making this style of pie crust, check out this guide on How to Make Crumb Crusts to read more about them and the alternatives to using graham crackers as the base.

Making the Crumbs

You can actually find store-bought graham cracker crumbs! So if you find them an want to use them, by all means. But most people already have some graham crackers at home, and it's just as easy to grind them up fresh yourself. Using a food processor or blender is the easiest method. However, some people find cleaning up a food processor to be a chore for such a little task. Smashing the crackers by hand is also an option. The simplest method is to put the crackers in a plastic bag, press out the air, seal it, and crush the contents with a rolling pin or meat pounder. However, some drawbacks to this method: it requires manual effort, can produce an uneven crumb texture, and might be time-consuming based on the amount you need to crush.

Whichever way you make them, aim for crumbs that are about the size of grains of sand, with as much evenness as possible. Some variation in texture is okay, but keep in mind that uneven pieces can result in a less-than-sturdy crust.

Troubleshooting

The amount of butter needed can vary due to differences in moisture and fat in various graham cracker brands. Start by adding a smaller amount of butter to the crumbs, adjusting as needed. It's useful to keep extra crumbs on hand to balance the texture—aim for a consistency similar to wet sand: when squeezed, it should hold together and compact easily without feeling sticky or greasy.

If the crumb mixture is extremely dry, add more melted butter–one tablespoon at a time–to the crumbs until they are evenly moistened. Alternatively, if your mixture is too wet and hard to work with, add more graham cracker crumbs until it easily clumps together.

How to Form the Crust

I used to avoid graham cracker crusts because I found them messy and fussy to press into the pan. When I ran my pie business, I never offered a pie with a graham cracker crust. That all changed when I discovered a more efficient way to form them: start by creating the edges of the crust first, then firmly press the crumb mixture into the bottom of the plate.

To Freeze or To Bake

Once it's shaped, the graham cracker crust can be par-baked or frozen before filling. Freezing solidifies the butter but doesn’t melt the sugar all the way to create a very strong bond, making it best for chilled pies. Par-baking it creates a crispier, more stable, more flavorful crust by melting the sugar and adding a toasty element. I prefer par-baking, but sometimes turning on the oven for just 10 minutes isn't practical. Choose the method that suits your needs best (and pie)!

Types of Pie to Use with a Graham Cracker Crust

A graham cracker crust can be used for creamy or chocolatey no-bake or icebox-style pies. However, it isn't as sturdy as regular pie pastry, so it isn't ideal for full-on fruit pies. Thin custards, like in a Classic Custard Pie, can also be tricky to pair with a crumb crust. Pouring a thin filling can cause the crumbs to break apart and rise to the top. While I've had some success (like in this Strawberry Cream Pie), it requires extra care, such as making a thick, well-packed crumb mixture.

Here are some pie ideas and suggestions that go well with a graham cracker crumb crust:

• Some chocolate pies (like this Brownie Pecan Pie or Malted Milk Chocolate Pie)
• No-bake cheesecake style pies (such as this Cherry Cream Cheese Pie or No-Bake Cannoli Pie )
• Thicker custard / baked cheesecake pies (such as this Pistachio and Mascarpone Pie or Roasted Plum Pie)
• Pudding pies, aka cream pies (like this Butterscotch Cream Pie or Pistachio Cream Pie)
• Ice cream pies (like this Baked Alaska Pie)

More Easy Pie Crusts

I am so honored when you make a recipe from my site! If you make this Graham Cracker Crust, please leave a star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating with your experience! If you have any questions about this recipe, feel free to comment here, and tag me on instagram!

Print

Full Recipe