Heirloom Tomato Galette

When fresh tomatoes are at their peak, make this Heirloom Tomato Galette. A homemade pie crust is wrapped around herby crème fraîche and juicy tomatoes, then baked with a sprinkle of cheese. Perfect for an appetizer or light dinner!

Herb and Crème Fraîche Tomato Galette

We can all agree that tomatoes on their own are near perfect. But you know what sends them over the edge? Wrapping them up in a flaky pastry, layered between herbed crème fraîche, sprinkled with savory cheese, and baked to perfection in a high heat oven. That’s what! Seriously, this Heirloom Tomato Galette is the best little dinner pie to make at the end of the summer when those cools nights are starting to creep their way in, but you still want to savor the last drops of summer. So let’s get to baking, shall we?

But first, what is a galette?

A galette is a simply a round pastry usually consisting of either a sweet or savory filling, wrapped up in a pie-dough-like-pastry. The name hails from France, but we all know and love the galette as basically a free-form pie!

Galettes are known for their rustic charm and the ease with which nearly anyone can turn out an instagram-worthy version of one, thanks to the utter simplicity required to make it. It is said, if you are intimidated with making a pie, start with a galette! (Though to be fair, you know you’ll never hear me say that. Pie making is easy, and anybody can do it. That’s my story, and I’m sticking to it!)

Let’s Talk Tomatoes

Part of the beauty of this galette is the variety of color you’ll have using those heirloom tomatoes. However, not using heirlooms isn’t a deal-breaker. This galette will still be beautiful with just red tomatoes!

It’s best to work with ripe but still firm tomatoes. If they’re too soft and watery, that will reflect itself in the galette.

The tomatoes needed to be prepped before the bake. After slicing them into 1/4″ rounds, they need to be salted and drained for about 15-30 minutes. They might not release a ton of liquid at this point, but after they’ve been salted, they should be patted dry with a paper towel to trap any remaining excess moisture.

This step is essential to make sure your galette doesn’t end up a soggy mess.

Cheese and Herbs and other Delicious Things

Don’t start rolling your eyes when I tell you you need to buy a fancy cream that has it’s origins from France. Crème fraîche is relatively simple to find in the grocery store, and the richness it provides as a counter to the tomatoes is worth it.

But if you don’t feel like shelling out the high price for it (it’s true, it is a bit expensive) you can make your own! All you need is cultured buttermilk and cream. Here is recipe for How to Make Crème Fraîche. Or…you can just spend the $4 and have it already made for you! Either way, don’t skip out on it.

The crème fraîche goes underneath the tomatoes and is combined with a good bunch of herbs and cheese. I am leaving it pretty loose in terms of what herbs and cheese I’m calling for here, as there is great flexibility in this recipe depending on what you have on hand or what you like.

Think about what goes well with tomatoes! I’ve given suggestions in the recipe below of course, but do think of them as suggestions and be open to using what you have in your garden or what is available at your local store. As far as cheese, think about a harder type of cheese such as parmesan, asiago, gruyere, or pecorino Romano. An Italian blend will also work well.

How to Form a Galette

I’ve got to be honest, I don’t see much of a difference between making a pie and making a galette except for the fact that one is baked in a pie dish and one isn’t. However, many people say they find making a galette less intimidating. I think the reason why those who are intimidated by making a pie and not by a galette is because a galette is viewed as very rustic and can be a little wonky and wobbly.

All this is to say, to form a galette you simply bring the sides of the pastry up over the edges of the filling and press or pleat them together. It doesn’t need to be perfect, but you do want to make sure the pastry is securely in place on top of the edges of the tomatoes.

Tips for Making a Galette

1. Roll out your dough to a rough 13″ circle. You do not have to make the circle exact, but I like measure and clean up the edges of my rolled out pastry with a pastry wheel to remove any jagged edges. This makes for a more uniform looking galette. If you prefer a more rustic galette, leave the pastry in it’s rolled out state.
2. Make sure to leave a rough 1-1/2 to 2″ border along the edge of the pastry to leave room for the fold.
3. For a more uniform pleat, use the same angle for each pleat that you make, and try to bring up the same amount of dough.
4. Make sure to brush it with an egg wash for that shiny golden sheen on the crust!
5. Chill your galette in the refrigerator before baking if your pie dough has become too warm while it has been formed. A warm pie dough means it could possibly collapse in the oven.
6. Similarly, make sure your oven is preheated. If the oven isn’t at the correct temperature, the galette might not hold it’s shape.

More Savory Pies

• Spinach Artichoke Quiche
• Easy Ham and Cheese Quiche
• Lentil Pot Pie
• Jalapeño Popper Hand Pies

Make sure to comment below and tag @everydaypie on Instagram if you make these Apple Pie Filling or if you have any questions!

Print